Brussels says it has dropped its open finance law in the name of simplification. My view is that it is clearing the decks for files that fit its tech and payments sovereignty agenda, and a messy open finance file did not fit. The cost will land somewhere few in Brussels are looking: AI agents that log in as the customer.
The European Commission has decided to stop legislating for open finance: its 2027 work programme, adopted on 4 November, puts the Financial Data Access Regulation (FiDA) on a list of 18 pending proposals it intends to withdraw within six months.
FiDA would have given consumers and businesses a legal right to share data on their savings, investments, pensions, and insurance with licensed third parties, through secure interfaces and with the customer in control of every permission.
I think dropping it is the wrong call, because customers are already handing their financial lives to AI assistants. Without an open finance framework, the agents acting for them will be forced to reach that data the old way, by logging in with the customer’s password.
This article explains why the Commission let FiDA go, why I think sovereignty priorities are also at play, why that would be the wrong reason for doing so, what open finance in the EU looks like without it, and how AI agents will reach customers’ financial data in the meantime.
Why the Commission is withdrawing FiDA
The Commission proposed FiDA on 28 June 2023, alongside PSD3 and the Payment Services Regulation (PSR). Trilogue negotiations (talks where Parliament, Council, and Commission agree a law’s final text) opened in April 2025 but have not met since that June. The withdrawal annex is blunt about the reason: the file has been “pending with co-legislators for more than three years”, with no trilogue since June 2025 and little chance of securing Council support (Open Banking Tracker).
Opposition came from several directions at once, starting with French authorities, who argued the costs would far exceed the Commission’s estimates and pressed for deep revisions or withdrawal. Insurers were among the loudest critics, and much of the wider financial services industry objected to FiDA’s scope and the cost of the technology builds it would demand. The sharpest dispute was over Big Tech: Parliament barred Digital Markets Act gatekeepers from becoming data users, the Council wanted an extra authorisation hurdle for them, and Berlin pushed to exclude them outright.
By the time the 2027 programme was drafted, the Commission’s priorities had moved on, with delivery of existing rules now ranked ahead of new proposals. The Commission has not cited sovereignty as a reason for dropping FiDA, but I think it is part of the story, with attention moving to files that fit a tech and payments sovereignty agenda more neatly. In payments, the political energy in Brussels and Frankfurt has shifted to cutting reliance on international card schemes, which handled around 61% of euro area card payments in 2022. Wero now counts 57 million users, and Parliament voted in July to open trilogue negotiations on the digital euro. My read is that a sprawling, contested open finance file did not fit that agenda, and few people in Brussels were still prepared to defend a data-access law that its critics mostly associated with cost and complexity.
Payment sovereignty would be the wrong reason for letting FiDA go
FiDA was always a sovereignty file, even if the debate rarely framed it that way. Its fiercest fight was over who gets to hold Europeans’ financial data, and both Parliament and Council moved to fence off the largest US platforms, with Germany arguing that an exclusion would protect consumers’ digital sovereignty. Withdrawing FiDA removes the only EU rulebook on access to financial data beyond payment accounts, so the limits on Big Tech gatekeepers that Parliament and Council both pushed for will never become law either.
This is where I think the sovereignty argument cuts the other way: PSD3, Wero, and the digital euro decide how money moves, but data on savings, pensions, and investments decides who builds the products, offers the advice, and develops the switching tools on top. EPI chief executive Martina Weimert makes a similar point about payments, arguing that the data attached to each transaction is a large part of what makes them strategic, and she defines sovereignty as “European players operating on European platforms under European rules”. For open finance, those European rules now stop at the payment account, which leaves Europe with only half a sovereignty strategy.
Simplification is the Commission’s stated reason, but the cost of open finance won’t disappear with the regulation. It will move to bilateral contracts, to national schemes, and to whatever access route the market finds in the absence of a common one.
What happens to open finance in the EU without FiDA?
Payment accounts are not affected, because PSD2 still applies and the PSR that replaces it is close to becoming law, with Parliament’s final vote provisionally scheduled for 14 December. Beyond payment accounts, open finance will move to industry schemes and commercial contracts, and Germany offers an early look at that model. The four German banking associations, including the cooperative banks’ BVR, launched giroAPI on 1 January 2025 on the Berlin Group’s openFinance framework, starting with payments and account information and planning to extend into open finance. By the time the first third-party provider was admitted in May 2025, more than 190 banks were in the scheme.
giroAPI is a genuine start, but a commercially governed scheme means the side holding the data will get to choose the partners, the price, and the pace, market by market. A provider serving several countries will face a separate set of terms in each, and PSD2 has already shown how far voluntary opening goes: few banks built APIs for small third parties until the law required it.
So I expect the regulated route to a customer’s pension, portfolio, or insurance policy to stay narrow, slow, and patchy for years, while customer demand for it keeps growing regardless.
How AI agents will reach financial data without FiDA
Customers now ask AI assistants to track spending, compare savings rates, and manage their money, and the Model Context Protocol (MCP) lets those assistants plug straight into data sources and tools. Where a proper API exists, regulated or commercial, the agent can use it: Danske Bank is piloting an MCP server that connects corporate customers’ AI assistants to its commercial Premium APIs, and in Denmark, Subaio’s MCP server gives assistants live bank data through PSD2-regulated open banking, with no passwords involved.
Where no such route exists, the agent logs in as the customer, taking the username and password, driving the website, and reading the screen. The US standards body FDX calls this an agentic-era version of screen scraping, and warns that agents may fall back on it whenever the API route cannot give them the data they need.
The US is already showing where this leads: in October, Axios reported that major banks had detected unvetted third-party AI agents operating inside customer accounts, and that many could not tell whether an agent’s activity was directed by the customer at all. JPMorgan Chase, Citi, Charles Schwab, and Wells Fargo have since moved to block agents that log in with customers’ credentials, or to push the risk onto the customer, and Bank of America has told customers that they are responsible for any activity resulting from credentials they share.
Yet JPMorgan, Citi, Schwab, and Wells Fargo all still let customers share read-only data through open banking providers, which tells me the lasting answer is a proper channel rather than a ban. Retail is working through the same question, with Amazon’s lawsuit against Perplexity’s Comet agent turning on who is actually accessing an account when software acts for the customer; the Ninth Circuit has so far found that it is the customer.
Europe has fought this battle before, and FiDA was meant to finish it
Europe has fought a version of this battle before, and it has taken more than a decade, from PSD2’s adoption in 2015 to a PSR that is only now nearing a final vote. The PSD2 technical standards, applied from 14 September 2019, banned traditional screen scraping, in which a third party impersonates the customer without identifying itself to the bank. Providers had to identify themselves with eIDAS certificates, banks that built dedicated interfaces had to make them perform as well as their own customer channels, and the PSR now tightens that regime further by listing the obstacles banks may not put in front of licensed providers.
FiDA was meant to bring the same identified-access regime to savings, investments, pensions, and insurance, and without it those accounts have none at all. This time, the scraper would be an AI agent holding the customer’s password and operating at scale.
Europe spent more than ten years getting third parties out of customers’ passwords, and I worry that dropping FiDA will invite them straight back in. The agents will reach savings, pension, and investment data either way; what FiDA would have decided is whether they arrive identified, with scoped consent and an audit trail, or anonymously, as the customer.
There is also an irony here that I think deserves more attention in Brussels. FiDA’s fiercest fight was over keeping the large US platforms away from Europeans’ financial data, yet without it, an AI assistant built by one of those same platforms needs no licence to reach a customer’s pension or portfolio, only the customer’s password. If, as I suspect, sovereignty is part of the reason for letting FiDA go, the question Brussels now has to answer is who it expects to be holding that password.
Sources
Regulation Tomorrow (Norton Rose Fulbright), European Commission publishes work programme 2027, 4 November 2026
Open Banking Tracker, The State of FIDA in 2026: The EU's Open Finance Law Is Being Withdrawn, 9 November 2026
Simmons & Simmons, FiDA Hub, 24 June 2025
Andres Lehtmets, European Commission's Annual Work Programme: FIDA Proposal to Be Withdrawn?, 10 February 2025
The Irish Times (Financial Times), EU to block Big Tech from new financial data sharing system, 21 September 2025
Banque de France, Most EU countries rely on international card schemes for card payments, ECB report shows, 28 February 2025
EPI Company, Wero Pulse and Figures, accessed 16 November 2026
Positive Money Europe, EU Parliament sends digital euro into final negotiations, 9 July 2026
TMI, Wero Leads Europe's Charge for Payments Sovereignty, interview with Martina Weimert (EPI) and Carlo Bovero (BNP Paribas)
Die Deutsche Kreditwirtschaft, German Banking Industry Committee has created the first standardised account API in Europe, 30 January 2025
Open Banking Expo, Token.io becomes first third-party provider admitted to giroAPI scheme, 27 May 2025
The Paypers, Danske Bank pilots MCP Server for corporate AI banking access, 15 September 2026
FF News, Subaio Launches MCP Server to Connect AI Assistants with Real-Time Bank Data, 6 November 2026
Financial Data Exchange (FDX), Agentic AI, Open Finance, & Technical Standards: Exploration Brief, April 2026
Axios, Scoop: Unvetted AI agents are accessing U.S. bank accounts, 22 October 2026
Hunton Andrews Kurth, Major Banks Move to Block or Limit Customer-Directed AI Agents, 3 November 2026
TechCrunch, Bank of America kindly asks that you don't share your banking password with your AI assistant, 27 October 2026
The Fashion Law, Amazon's Perplexity Case Is Becoming a Test of Who Controls AI Commerce, 23 September 2026
Jones Day, EU Regulatory Technical Standards for Strong Customer Authentication Enter Into Force, March 2018